Medical Equipment Design and the Critical Nature of Interconnection
Mon, 08/15/2005 - 7:59am
Medical equipment such as patient monitors, scanners, electronic catheters, and therapeutic devices require dependable connectivity and accurate signal transmission. This exclusive report discusses the challenges inherent with interconnect selection and offers advice for designers of today’s medical electronics systems.
Figure 1: The use of color-coded connectors can help avoid mismating, which can be a safety risk in certain medical applications. These HyperGrip interconnects incorporate a mechanism for color-coding the connectors as required during assembly.
Safeguards and options
The “personality chip” issue
Tom Kannally is the global industry director for medical applications at Hypertronics Corp., 16 Brent Dr., Hudson, MA 01749, and has worked in the interconnect field for more than 20 years. Hypertronics is a global provider of high-performance electrical connector and interconnect solutions for demanding applications. Kannally can be reached at 978-568-0451 or email@example.com.
By Tom Kannally
Designing systems for the medical market requires careful attention to eliminate every possible avenue for failure or loss of functionality. Interconnects are especially vulnerable because they are one of the most exposed areas, with a high likelihood of being damaged by environmental factors or poor usage. In the medical arena, there are many considerations to keep in mind when selecting connectors to ensure that their performance and reliability are maximized throughout their life.
The potential of mating connectors that don’t belong together is a safety risk in many medical applications. System developers can build in safeguards by using an appropriate form of color-coding, which provides a visual indication of a correct match between a plug and receptacle, as illustrated in Figure 1.
Frequently, the system of color-coding has to be decided when the connectors are purchased from the supplier because the color will be an unchangeable feature of the plastic housing. However, some connectors offer greater flexibility. Interconnects, for example, can incorporate a mechanism for color-coding the connectors as required during assembly. The colors assigned to the receptacle and plug can be chosen through the use of interchangeable and differently colored silicone rings and strain reliefs, respectively.
Keyed ConnectorsIncorrect mating also can be avoided by using keyed connectors. These incorporate a mechanism that physically prevents the plug and receptacle from being mated if they are an unmatched pair.
There are various options to consider here. One is to use connectors that, while identical in every other respect, have fixed keys that are part of the connector body. However, it is also possible to purchase connectors with customizable keying, which can help lower the cost of inventory. For example, some designs allow users to alter the keying of the connector by changing the position of an insert.
In one case, six different positions are possible, affording the developer the flexibility to alter the interconnect configuration as the system requirements evolve. Mismating is prevented by a plastic barrier between plug and receptacle, which is positioned in such a way that only compatible connectors will be able to mate. Such an approach reduces the possibility of contact damage compared to connectors where the contacts themselves provide the physical barrier that prevents mismating.
Mating CyclesIn medical applications, especially those with a safety-critical function, care must be taken to ensure that a plug and receptacle remain interconnected reliably. One consideration is to be sure that the connector has been specified for a sufficiently high number of mating cycles.
Some of the connectors used in patient monitoring equipment, for example, have to be mated and unmated many times a day over a lifetime of many years. Depending on the type of system, the connector may have to endure up to 100,000 mating cycles during its life. The typical high-quality medical, military, or industrial connector, which might be specified to perform reliably for 500 mating cycles, is unsuitable for this application.
An additional consideration is the degree of shock and vibration present in the usage environment. For instance, if the equipment has to be used in an ambulance, care should be taken to choose connectors that are specified for this kind of use.
Figure 2: The wire basket construction of this hyperboloid contact system provides a reliable contact but doesn’t require a high normal-force.
The reliability of an interconnectits ability to perform over a long life or in demanding situationsis largely determined by the contact design. A point of vulnerability is the cantilever-beam spring mechanism conventionally used in a connector’s construction. The high normal-force required with these interconnects not only results in high mating forces but has a tendency to cause the spring to wear out.
System developers can eliminate this weakness by using a connector with an alternative contact design. For example, a hyperboloid contact system with a wire basket construction, as shown in Figure 2, provides a reliable contact but doesn’t require a high normal-force. As a result, connectors are inserted with smooth and low-force mating between pin and socket. This provides greatly increased longevity compared to many other connector technologies. Connectors with hyperboloid contacts can withstand up to 100,000 mating cycles. Another benefit of the hyperboloid wire basket contact is the enhanced wiping action that cleans the contact mating surfaces as the pin pushes past the spring wires during mating.
In situations where one-half of a connector forms part of a disposable element, such as an electronic catheter, but the other half must perform reliably for many thousands of mating cycles, it is tempting for developers to attempt to engineer the disposable half themselves to reduce costs. This practice should be avoided. It is easy to underestimate the engineering effort required to make certain types of high-reliability connectors. Electrical problems or damage to equipment can be prevented by ensuring that the connector supplier has designed both the plug and receptacle.
Plug and PlayMedical appliances are increasingly incorporating plug-and-play functionality to simplify the process of connecting different pieces of equipment. To support such a capability, the design normally includes additional electronics or intelligence. For instance, some kind of “personality chip” is used to communicate with the host system, providing details of the identity or status of the appliance. This device may be located in the equipment itself or it may be incorporated, for electrical reasons, into the connector housing.
System developers can choose to implement this additional functionality themselves. However, if it’s to be included in a connector, they should be careful to avoid compromising the connector design. This might cause a significant degradation in properties including its high reliability or high-cycle life. It is often worthwhile to specify this additional functionality directly from the connector manufacturer.
Cleaning and SterilizationIt may also be important to ensure that connectors withstand exposure to some of the cleaning and sterilization methods used in certain medical environments. For example, patient-monitoring equipment often has to be cleaned or sterilized before use. Different approaches are used, ranging from soap and water to harsher methods involving alcohol, ethylene oxide gas, and gamma radiation. In addition, high-temperature steam autoclaving is widely used for cables, tools, and other accessories.
Non-Magnetic MaterialsMagnetic components positioned in close proximity to the RF coil in an MRI scanner tend to cast a shadow on the resulting image. Developers of MRI scanners have made much effort to eliminate magnetic materials from their designs in recent years. Non-magnetic connectors are increasingly available to support this requirement.
However, there can be trade-offs, since non-magnetic materials typically do not provide electrical and mechanical properties to match those of the many magnetic contact materials in common use. Some manufacturers have effectively addressed the performance requirements of MRI scanners with non-magnetic variants of high-reliability connectors, incorporating them into fully non-magnetic cable assemblies and interconnect subsystems.
ConclusionGiven the unusual requirements present when specifying medical connectors, it’s important to pay attention to all elements of the design early in the development stage. Connectors frequently are considered after much of the design has taken shape. This can be problematic if the connectors used for the prototype do not support the requisite number of mating cycles or if the connectors are vulnerable to damage from medical cleaning agents. Although connector suppliers can engineer a custom solution if such problems arise, designers can avoid this extra expense by considering interconnect requirements early in the design process.
For additional information on the technologies discussed in this article, see Medical Design Technology online at www.mdtmag.com or Hypertronics Corp. at www.hypertronics.com.